Home insurance renewals tend to show up a month or two before your policy ends, often with a higher price and no explanation. Before you pay it or start shopping, give the renewal's declarations page fifteen minutes. A lot of the surprises people run into after a claim were sitting on that page the whole time.

Dwelling coverage: enough to rebuild, not to resell

The biggest number on the page is usually dwelling coverage, sometimes labeled Coverage A. It should reflect what it would cost to rebuild your house from the ground up. That's a different number from what you paid for the place or what it would sell for, and the land isn't part of it, since land doesn't burn down.

Rebuilding can cost more than people expect, especially after a big storm or wildfire, when every contractor in the region is booked. Ask your insurer how it arrived at your figure. Then ask whether you have extended replacement cost coverage, which pays a set percentage above your limit (25% or 50% is common) if rebuilding runs over.

Replacement cost or actual cash value

These two phrases decide how much you're paid when something is damaged. Replacement cost pays what it takes to replace it with something new and similar. Actual cash value pays what the old thing was worth after depreciation.

The difference adds up fast. On paper, a 15-year-old roof is worth a fraction of a new one. Some insurers now pay actual cash value for older roofs while keeping replacement cost for the rest of the house. Look for wording like "roof surfacing payment schedule" in your policy or renewal paperwork, and ask what it means for your roof's age.

Deductibles, especially the percentage kind

Most policies have a flat deductible, like $1,000 or $2,500. Many homes in coastal and storm-prone areas also carry a separate deductible for wind, hail or hurricanes that's a percentage of the dwelling coverage.

That percentage is easy to misread. A 2% hurricane deductible on a house insured for $350,000 is $7,000, not $2,000. Better to learn that now than while you're waiting on a roofer.

Raising your regular deductible is one of the more dependable ways to lower the premium. Just make sure the new deductible is money you actually have, ideally sitting in an emergency fund.

What the policy won't cover

Standard homeowners policies don't cover flooding. Flood insurance is a separate policy, sold through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer, and an NFIP policy usually takes 30 days to kick in. FEMA says about a third of NFIP claims from 2013 to 2023 came from areas outside high-risk flood zones, so "we're not in a flood zone" isn't the end of the conversation.

Earthquake damage is excluded too. So is water that backs up through a drain or sewer line, unless you add a water backup endorsement. Ask your insurer what that endorsement costs; you may decide it's worth it.

Your claims history follows you

Insurers share claims information through databases, and the largest is LexisNexis's C.L.U.E. It generally holds up to seven years of home and auto claims tied to you and your property. The Fair Credit Reporting Act entitles you to a free copy, and you can dispute anything that's wrong.

That's also a reason to think twice about small claims. A $1,800 claim on a $1,000 deductible puts $800 in your pocket, and then sits on your record for years where it can affect what you pay. Some homeowners decide to cover small losses themselves and save the policy for the big ones.

Then shop, with the same coverage

Once you know what you have, get quotes with the same dwelling limit, deductibles and add-ons. An independent agent can quote several insurers at once. Your credit may also affect the price; Experian's summary of state rules lists California, Maryland and Massachusetts among the states that bar insurers from using it to set homeowners rates.

If you pay your premium through your mortgage escrow account, send the new declarations page to your mortgage servicer when you switch so the payment goes to the right company. Then confirm the old policy is canceled and ask when your refund will arrive.