Every insurer prices policies with its own formula. One leans hard on your ZIP code, another on your credit, another on the car you drive. That's how the same person can get quotes hundreds of dollars apart. It's also how the cheapest quote can turn out to be cheap for a reason: lower limits, a bigger deductible, or a coverage that quietly fell off.

Start with your declarations page

Your current policy has a summary page, usually called the declarations page, that spells out exactly what you're paying for. It's in your insurer's app or online account. Pull it up before you ask for a single quote and write down:

Have each driver's license number and each car's VIN handy too, along with the dates of any accidents or tickets in the past few years. With all of that in one place, the quote forms go much faster.

Quote the same coverage everywhere

Ask each company for the limits and deductibles you have now. If you want to change something, change it on every quote at the same time. Otherwise you're comparing two different products and calling one of them cheaper.

Be careful with quotes built on your state's minimum liability limits. The minimums are low, and in many states they wouldn't come close to covering a serious injury or a new car. If you cause a crash and the damage runs past your limits, you can be personally responsible for the rest.

The one spot where trimming coverage often makes sense is an older car you own outright. Collision and comprehensive pay up to the car's value, minus the deductible. If the car is worth $3,000 and your deductible is $1,000, you're paying every year to protect $2,000. Compare that against what those two coverages cost you.

Your credit may count, depending on your state

In most states, insurers can use a credit-based insurance score to help set your price. A handful of states limit that. According to Experian's summary of state rules, California, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Michigan don't allow credit to be used in setting auto rates, and Maryland, Oregon and Utah restrict how it can be used.

Getting quotes won't hurt your credit score. Insurers check with a soft inquiry, which doesn't affect your score.

When to shop

The best window is about a month before your policy renews. You'll have time to compare without a deadline, and some insurers knock a little off the price if you buy several days before the policy starts.

It's also worth getting fresh quotes after anything that changes how you look on paper:

Discounts worth asking about

Online quote forms catch the obvious discounts, but it's worth asking a person anyway. Common ones include bundling with home or renters insurance, paying the full term up front, paperless billing and autopay, good-student discounts for young drivers, and defensive driving courses, which some states require insurers to reward for older drivers.

Usage-based programs, where an app or plug-in device tracks how you drive, can lower your rate if you drive gently and not very much. Before you sign up, ask whether the program can also raise your rate. With some insurers, it can.

Switching without a gap

Don't cancel your old policy until the new one is in force. Even a short lapse can make you look riskier to insurers later, and driving without insurance is illegal in nearly every state.

  1. Buy the new policy with a specific start date, and save the new ID cards to your phone.
  2. Call your old insurer and cancel effective that same day. Ask when you'll get a refund for any unused premium.
  3. If the car is financed or leased, send the new declarations page to your lender, which requires proof of coverage.