Credit card debt is expensive. In the third quarter of 2026, the average rate on card accounts that were charged interest was 22.36%, according to the Federal Reserve. If you're carrying balances on more than one card, the order you pay them off changes how much that interest ends up costing you.

There are two popular ways to pick the order:

Both share the habit that does most of the work: you keep paying the same total every month, even as individual cards drop off.

The example

Here's a household with three cards and $12,500 in total debt. They can afford $550 a month, which is $220 more than the combined minimums.

CardBalanceAPRMinimum
Credit union card$1,80017.99%$40
Store card$3,10029.99%$100
Bank card$7,60023.49%$190

The snowball goes after the credit union card first because it's the smallest. The avalanche starts with the store card because its rate is highest, and leaves the credit union card for last.

We ran both plans month by month, keeping the minimums fixed and the total payment at $550:

SnowballAvalanche
First card paid offMonth 8Month 12
Debt-freeMonth 31Month 31
Total interest paid$4,465$4,081

The avalanche saved $384. Both plans finished in the same month. The snowball's first payoff came four months sooner.

That's a pretty typical outcome. The avalanche never costs more than the snowball, but how much it saves depends on how far apart the rates are and how large the low-rate balances are. If your smallest balance also carries your highest rate, the two methods are the same plan.

What the research says

Economists tend to prefer the avalanche. Behavioral researchers have found reasons to take the snowball seriously.

In a 2012 study, David Gal and Blakeley McShane of Northwestern's Kellogg School of Management looked at records from nearly 6,000 people in a debt settlement program. The people who closed out more of their individual accounts were more likely to finish the program, even when the dollars they'd paid down were the same.

A separate set of experiments, published in 2011 by Moty Amar, Dan Ariely, Shahar Ayal, Cynthia Cryder and Scott Rick, found the flip side. People strongly prefer to wipe out small balances, even when doing so means paying more interest. The researchers called it debt account aversion.

Put together, the research points to a sensible middle ground. The snowball costs you something. If an early win is what keeps you going, it may be worth paying for, because a plan you quit in month five saves nothing.

How to choose

What makes either plan work

If the minimums are already too much

Both methods assume you can pay more than the minimums. If you can't, there are other routes, each with trade-offs: